Non-Compete Clauses: What's Actually Enforceable for Dentists

The Federal Trade Commission's sweeping nationwide ban on non-competes is dead, so almost every dental associate contract includes some form of non-compete clause. But "it's in the contract" doesn't automatically mean "it's enforceable." Understanding the difference matters both before you sign and, if it comes to it, after you leave.

Why non-competes are so common. Practices invest real time and money training associates and building their patient base. A non-compete is meant to protect that investment by preventing an associate from leaving and immediately opening up down the street with the same patients.

What courts generally look at. Enforceability typically turns on three factors: geographic scope (is the restricted area reasonable relative to where the practice actually draws patients?), duration (is one to two years reasonable, or is five years excessive?), and whether the restriction protects a legitimate business interest without being unnecessarily punitive. Courts in different states weigh these factors differently, and some jurisdictions restrict or ban non-competes for licensed professionals altogether.

Why this varies so much by state. Because non-compete law is state-specific and changes over time through both legislation and case law, a clause that's fully enforceable in one state may be unenforceable — or heavily modified by a court — in another. This is exactly the kind of question that requires review by a licensed attorney familiar with your specific jurisdiction, not a general rule of thumb.

Negotiating a non-compete before you sign. The best time to address an unreasonable non-compete is before you sign, not after you've decided to leave. Common negotiation points include shrinking the radius, shortening the duration, or adding a carve-out if you're terminated without cause.

What happens if you break one. If you leave and practice within a restricted area during the restricted period, you may face a lawsuit seeking an injunction, damages, or both. Whether the practice can actually enforce it depends heavily on how the clause was drafted and your state's law — which is precisely why a pre-signing review matters so much.

/